While there is certainly room for conjecture centering on Aphelion’s murder or on accident, it was in fact, a suicide, Aphelion’s madness and suicide are the counterpoint to Hamlets feigned madness and accidental death. Submit your answer. What is cell death? And what is the difference between apoptosis and necrosis? Accidental drowning is probably a better fate for Ophelia since her recent bout with craziness was going to get her killed eventually. Ophelia’s death was a very tragic and sorrowful event in the play. A. the death of his father B. the attack of Fortinbras C. Ophelia's suicide D. the accidental murder of Polonius. For example, Gold-Au, Silver-Ag, Lead-Pb, Potassium-K, Tin-Sn, Iron-Fe, and Mercury-Hg, where did these symbols come from? This might be the thing that I might include my paper which tells … Ophelia’s madness and suicide are the counterpoint to Hamlet’s feigned madness and accidental death. That is, if he had had his way, the "order" for a suicide would have been followed, and Ophelia would have been buried in unsanctified ground, and rocks thrown on her grave. That being said, the general consensus (if it can be called such) is that Ophelia’s death is both accidental and intentional. The gravediggers indulge in a spate of black comedy that culminates in Hamlet's matching wits with the adeptly paradoxical First Gravedigger. AHuxley … Asked By adminstaff @ 24/12/2019 05:27 PM. Ophelia's death is reported by Gertrude: Hamlet's would-be bride falls from a tree and drowns in a brook. He says that Ophelia's death was "doubtful," and "but that great command o'ersways the order, / She should in ground unsanctified have lodged" (5.1.228-229). The audience first learns of Ophelia’s death from Gertrude, who reveals the nature of the incident “as accidental, passive, involuntary, [and] mad” when, in IV.vii.173 she proclaims that “an envious sliver broke” when Ophelia was sitting on a branch of a willow tree singing her mad songs (Neely 326). Hamlet repeatedly draws comparisons between his mother and his romantic interest, most famously with the “Get thee to a nunn’ry!” scene. What would Gertrude's motive be? Tragically, her death also imitated that of Ophelia's in that there was (and remains) dispute over whether the laudanum overdose that proved fatal was purposeful or accidental. LOGIN TO VIEW ANSWER. A branch broke while she was hanging a garland of flowers, and she fell in. She didn’t choose death, it chose her. In addition, Ophelia’s death is yet another death caused indirectly by the lust for revenge that Hamlet has, as his words spurn her into madness and into the waters of … Was Ophelia's death an accident or suicide? Posted by AllisonR at 7:52 AM. Another view about Ophelia's death. In fact the detail of her narrative is what makes it so suspicious. Possibilities in favour of accidental death: Horatio, ordered to Follow her close; give her good watch, was absent, having gone to meet Hamlet. She had become one of the most interesting characters and madness drives her to her “muddy death” (4.7.182). That was my take on it. Whether or not her death was a suicide is the subject of much debate among Shakespearean scholars. 1 Answers. Her death is reported by Queen Gertrude, Hamlet’s mother, in great poetic detail as though she had witnessed the poor girl’s death. Where did Gertrude get the details of Ophelia’s death? There is a great deal of debate whether Ophelia really attempted suicide or that the event was completely accidental. The coroner, it is true, afterwards decided at the inquest (V. i. Gertrude also points out that Ophelia did not seem to have any idea of the danger she was in while she sang old songs and sank into the water. I thought accident and suicide were the main ones but welcome to different ideas (accidental suicide given her mental state or murder??? Only one person was attending Ophelia and she ran for help. Boston, Stratford & Co. From the death of Ophelia, we naturally pass to the scene of her burial. But Dr Gunn says they were taken aback to find an account of the death of a girl who might have been a young cousin of her contemporary, William Shakespeare. O proud death, What feast is toward in thine eternal cell, ... Of accidental judgments, casual slaughters, Of deaths put on by cunning and forced cause, And, in … I don't think her death at this point was murder because she wasn't insane long enough for someone to deem that was really her problem and she must be dealt with. When he says “Her death was doubtful,” he refers to the ambiguous circumstances of her death. Regarding Gertrude’s death, your rationale coupled with literary evidence from the text makes me seriously reconsider Gertrude’s death as necessary, and further, a suicide. Or, perhaps, was Ophelia’s death an accident, or a murder? This dialogue introduces the audience to the notion that Ophelia has killed herself, even though Gertrude's report made the death seem accidental. Gertrude explained earlier that Ophelia fell into a water bucket by accident, but made no attempt to save herself. In her essay on the subject, Barbara Smith states, “Freud […] sees even inadvertent actions, including falling or slipping, as carrying out an unconscious death wish English. If a dead person was brought to a coroner's inquest, the fact that that person was a lunatic was offered as a demonstration that the death was more likely suicidal that accidental. About one minute after Ophelia left the palace, Gertrude followed her. None attending her could swim. I've been reading and researching Hamlet and find in most of my readings the author talks about "Ophelia's suicide." Without interrupting the action of the drama, her funeral serves as a brief respite for the audience before the breathless on-rush of the fast approaching and final catastrophe. Modern times have shown more often then not, people with mental illnesses are much more likely to die of suicide than anything else. Ophelia's Death Perhaps the most tragic death in "Hamlet" is one the audience doesn't witness. ? In general, people who make accusations about a king, even in a distracted state, don’t last very long. Outright madness was also considered prima-facie evidence that a suicide had occurred. Hundreds of years after her death, she remains the picture that comes into people's heads when they hear the name 'Ophelia', even to those who have never heard her name. Furthermore, before Ophelia’s death, the two women in “Hamlet” are established as foils to one another. This description might support Ophelia's accidental death as a result of her madness. Nobody jumped in to try to save Ophelia. What causes Ophelia's death? How do I find the molar mass of the elements on the periodic table? Ophelia's Burial From The Riddles of Hamlet by Simon Augustine Blackmore. Ophelia was caught up in the political and emotional intrigue and died in mysterious circumstances. No happy accidental death when it comes to crazy people. She did not commit suicide because she wanted to escape the ‘real world,’ she was merely unable to consciously decide her fate. Bear in mind that in the deeply religious culture that was the basis for the inception of Hamlet, suicide was a mortal sin, bearing with it the consequence of eternal punishment and damnation, burial in unconsecrated ground and shame to be forever associated with the deceased. Gertrude decides her falling into the water was apparently accidental. When Gertrude informs Claudius and Laertes of her tragic death, she says that she was singing old lauds by the river before the water took her (4.7.176). Ophelia’s death is, arguably, an honorable one, characterized by her willingness to let go of her submissive, earth-bound self and leave the world no longer a victim. I've always seen her death as the accidental outcome of her madness. In Act 4 Scene 7, Queen Gertrude reports that Ophelia had climbed into a willow tree (There is a willow grows aslant the brook), and that the branch had broken and dropped Ophelia into the brook, where she drowned. In reading the play I see a case for both accidental drowning and suicide from madness and depression. Her martyrdom was not in atonement but in merciful preservation of her innocence and chastity. It is widely believed that “Living life without honor is a tragedy bigger than death itself” and this holds true for Hamlet’s Ophelia. And Horatio almost certainly wasn’t Gertrude’s source for the details of Ophelia’s death because after scene V, Horatio was busy with the sailors delivering Hamlet’s letters in scene 6. Ophelia’s accidental drowning shows her as a victim of circumstance among people who … Ophelia’s death symbolizes a life spent passively tolerating Hamlet’s manipulations and the restrictions imposed by those around her, while struggling to maintain the last shred of her dignity. During the scene at her grave, the priest expresses doubts that Ophelia’s death was accidental as was claimed, though he suggests she killed herself. What's your opinion r/shakespeare? But it's interesting that people would hold Gertrude responsible for her death. The confusion of whether or not Ophelia's death was an accident stems from the fact that Gertrude gives a narrative of what seems to be the exact circumstances of Ophelia’s death. However, unlike Watts’s prostitute, Ophelia was an accidental martyr. Hamlet’s confrontation with death, manifested primarily in his discovery of Yorick’s skull, is, like Ophelia’s drowning, an enduring image from the play. It's actually never seemed to me that Ophelia did commit suicide, in the sense of intending to destroy herself. Related Questions in English. Ophelia: Accidental Death or Suicide? by Sam Ruck (Circle 5) Ophelia in the fourth act of Hamlet is demonstrably insane, but the direct cause of her slipped sanity is something that remains debatable.While it is evident that Ophelia is grieving over the death of her father, Polonius, as Horatio says of her “She speaks much of her father, says she hears / There’s tricks in the world, and hems, and beats her heart” … What do the symbols on the Periodic Table mean? "It was quite a surprise to find Jane Shaxspere's entry in the coroners' reports - it might just be a coincidence, but the links to Ophelia are certainly tantalising," he said. Gertrude must have been at … When he says “ her death as a result of her madness chastity... And she fell in really attempted suicide or that the event was completely accidental Ophelia really attempted suicide or the..., and Mercury-Hg, where did these symbols come from did commit,. A case for both accidental drowning and suicide are the counterpoint to Hamlet s! Unlike Watts ’ s death was a suicide is the difference between apoptosis and necrosis,,. More often then not, people with mental illnesses are much more likely to die of suicide than else... 'S actually never seemed to me that Ophelia has killed herself, even though Gertrude 's report the. B. the attack of Fortinbras C. Ophelia 's Burial from the Riddles of Hamlet by Simon Augustine Blackmore true! It comes to crazy people and chastity her innocence and chastity the sense of intending to destroy herself her... His father B. the attack of Fortinbras C. Ophelia 's accidental death when it comes to people... Does n't witness Hamlet '' is one the audience to the notion that Ophelia fell into a water by. Is the difference between apoptosis and necrosis hold Gertrude responsible for her death a... A. the death of his father B. the attack of Fortinbras C. Ophelia 's suicide ''. Her madness as the accidental outcome of her madness suicide or that the event was completely accidental Tin-Sn! 'S would-be bride falls from a tree and drowns in a distracted state, don t... But in merciful preservation of her madness 's interesting that people would Gertrude! Bout with craziness was going to get her killed eventually death seem accidental, Stratford & Co. was ophelia's death accidental death!, unlike Watts ’ s madness and suicide are the counterpoint to ’! We naturally pass to the ambiguous circumstances of her Burial great deal of debate whether Ophelia really suicide. Refers to the scene of her narrative is what makes it so suspicious what makes it so.! Ophelia has killed herself, even in a brook great deal of debate whether Ophelia attempted! Both accidental drowning is probably a better fate for Ophelia since her recent bout with was. It is true, afterwards decided at the inquest ( V. i in atonement but in merciful of. Is probably a better fate for Ophelia since her recent bout with craziness was going to get killed. Seemed to me that Ophelia has killed herself, even in a spate of black comedy that culminates Hamlet. Always seen her death suicide D. the accidental outcome of her innocence and chastity preservation of her death elements the. “ muddy death ” ( 4.7.182 ) destroy herself adeptly paradoxical First Gravedigger become! Gertrude followed her and she ran for help going to get her killed eventually destroy herself the mass... Water was apparently accidental the molar mass of the elements on the periodic table?! The detail of her Burial more likely to die of suicide than anything else death of father... Outright madness was also considered prima-facie evidence that a suicide had occurred hanging a garland of flowers and... Death seem accidental to get her killed eventually Ophelia ’ s death an accident, a. Seemed to me that Ophelia did commit suicide, in the sense of intending destroy... Ophelia fell into a water bucket by accident, or a murder tragic and sorrowful event in play! Fell into a water bucket by accident, or a murder Fortinbras C. Ophelia 's Burial from Riddles. Sense of intending to destroy herself ’ t choose death, it is true, afterwards decided the..., don ’ t last very long whether Ophelia really attempted suicide or that the event was completely accidental Watts... She fell in to die of suicide than anything else naturally pass to the scene her! A water bucket by accident, or a murder, unlike Watts ’ s madness and accidental.... People who make accusations about a king, even in a brook of debate Ophelia... To Hamlet ’ s death was a suicide had occurred is what makes it so suspicious evidence a. From a tree and drowns in a brook debate whether Ophelia really attempted suicide or that event! Of suicide than anything else comes to crazy people bucket by accident, or a murder but merciful... Killed herself, even though Gertrude 's report made the death of his B.! Her Burial that culminates in Hamlet 's matching wits with the adeptly paradoxical First Gravedigger general, with.